For a federal employee, service member or contractor who holds a security clearance, a DUI arrest raises two separate questions: what happens in court, and what happens to your eligibility for access to classified information. Northern Virginia is home to many clearance holders, and the two processes run on different tracks under different rules. The way the criminal case ends becomes part of the record an adjudicator reviews.
A DUI and your clearance at a glance
- An arrest is reportable: Under federal reporting rules, people with access to classified information must report arrests, not only convictions.
- DUI is named in the guidelines: The adjudicative guidelines list "driving while under the influence" as an alcohol-related incident that could raise a security concern.
- It is not automatic: A single DUI does not by itself decide eligibility. Adjudicators weigh the whole person, including how long ago it happened and what you have done since.
- Court orders matter: Failing to complete a court-ordered alcohol program, or violating probation, is a separate concern under the guidelines.
The rules that apply
Clearance decisions across the executive branch are governed by Security Executive Agent Directive 4 (SEAD 4), the National Security Adjudicative Guidelines, effective June 8, 2017. SEAD 4 states that it supersedes all previously issued national security adjudicative guidelines. An earlier version of the guidelines is still published in the Code of Federal Regulations at 32 CFR Part 147.
SEAD 4 sets out 13 guidelines. A DUI usually touches three of them: Guideline G (alcohol consumption), Guideline J (criminal conduct) and Guideline E (personal conduct).
Guideline G: alcohol consumption
SEAD 4 states the concern this way: "Excessive alcohol consumption often leads to the exercise of questionable judgment or the failure to control impulses, and can raise questions about an individual's reliability and trustworthiness."
Conditions that could raise a concern include:
- "alcohol-related incidents away from work, such as driving while under the influence," regardless of how often the person drinks or whether there is a diagnosis
- habitual or binge drinking to the point of impaired judgment
- "failure to follow any court order regarding alcohol education, evaluation, treatment, or abstinence"
Conditions that could mitigate the concern include:
- so much time has passed, or the behavior was so infrequent or happened under such unusual circumstances, that it is unlikely to recur and does not cast doubt on current reliability, trustworthiness or judgment
- the person acknowledges a pattern of maladaptive alcohol use, has taken action to overcome it, and has shown a clear and established pattern of modified consumption or abstinence in line with treatment recommendations
- participation in, or successful completion of, counseling or a treatment program
Guideline J and Guideline E
Criminal conduct. Under Guideline J, evidence of criminal conduct can raise a concern "regardless of whether the individual was formally charged, prosecuted, or convicted." Being on probation, violating probation, or failing to complete a court-mandated rehabilitation program are listed as separate conditions. Mitigating conditions include the passage of time without recurrence, and "no reliable evidence to support that the individual committed the offense."
Personal conduct. Guideline E focuses on candor. It says a refusal to give "full, frank, and truthful answers" to investigators and security officials will normally result in an unfavorable determination.
Reporting a DUI arrest
Security Executive Agent Directive 3 (SEAD 3), Reporting Requirements for Personnel with Access to Classified Information or Who Hold a Sensitive Position, took effect June 12, 2017. It lists arrests and alcohol- and drug-related treatment among the activities that must be reported, both for people with Secret or Confidential access and for those with Top Secret access. SEAD 3 also says agency heads may impose additional reporting requirements, so the exact procedure and timing come from your agency or facility security officer.
How the whole-person concept works
SEAD 4 tells adjudicators to weigh, among other factors:
- the nature, extent and seriousness of the conduct
- the circumstances surrounding it
- how often and how recently it happened
- your age and maturity at the time
- the presence or absence of rehabilitation and other permanent behavioral changes
- the likelihood that it will continue or recur
That is why the details of the criminal case matter. A dismissal, an acquittal or a conviction for a lesser offense is a different record from a DUI conviction. Completing the Alcohol Safety Action Program (ASAP), installing and maintaining an ignition interlock, and following every term of probation are part of the record too.
How Jad defends a DUI when a clearance is at stake
Jad handles the criminal case. Questions about the clearance itself belong with your security officer or a lawyer who handles clearance matters. What Jad does in court shapes the record they will read.
- The charge itself. Jad tests the stop, the arrest and the breath or blood test. Where the evidence has weaknesses, he negotiates with the prosecutor. Where it doesn't hold up, he takes the case to trial.
- The court's orders. If there is a conviction, Jad explains each condition the court imposes so that ASAP, any interlock and any probation terms are completed on time.
- The paperwork. Jad makes sure you leave with the final order and disposition, so the outcome you report is documented accurately.
The firm's blog also has an article on DUI charges and security clearances.