Everyone who drives on a Virginia highway has agreed, by law, to give a breath or blood sample if arrested for DUI. Refusing that test after an arrest is a separate case with its own one-year license suspension, and a second refusal of a breath test is a crime. The handheld test at the roadside is different, and you can decline it.
Refusal at a glance
- First refusal: A civil offense, not a crime, with a one-year license suspension. The court can grant a restricted license with an ignition interlock.
- Second breath refusal within 10 years: A Class 1 misdemeanor and a three-year license loss.
- Second blood refusal within 10 years: Still a civil offense, but with a three-year license loss.
- At arrest: A refusal triggers the same immediate administrative suspension as a failed breath test: 7 days on a first offense.
- Your record: Virginia DMV lists refusal as a 6-point violation that stays on your driving record for 11 years.
The roadside test and the test after arrest
The roadside test. Before an arrest, an officer may offer a handheld preliminary breath test. Under Va. Code § 18.2-267 you have the right to refuse it, and the officer must tell you so. Neither the result nor a refusal can be used as evidence at a DUI trial. Declining it is not a refusal under § 18.2-268.3.
The test after arrest. Va. Code § 18.2-268.2 says that anyone who drives on a Virginia highway has consented to a breath or blood test if arrested for DUI within three hours of the alleged offense. After an arrest for alcohol, you must give a breath sample. A blood test is given instead if a breath test is unavailable or you are physically unable to take one. If the officer has reasonable cause to suspect drugs, you may also be required to give blood.
Breath refusal and blood refusal are treated differently
Va. Code § 18.2-268.3 punishes only an unreasonable refusal, and it separates breath from blood:
| Breath refusal | Blood refusal | |
|---|---|---|
| First offense | Civil offense; 1-year license suspension | Civil offense; 1-year license suspension |
| Within 10 years of a prior refusal, DUI or related offense | Class 1 misdemeanor; 3-year license loss | Civil offense; 3-year license loss |
| Restricted license on a first offense | Available, with an interlock | Available, with an interlock |
A Class 1 misdemeanor carries up to 12 months in jail and a fine of up to $2,500. Every refusal suspension is added to the administrative suspension at arrest under Va. Code § 46.2-391.2.
The advisement form
A refusal case rests on paperwork. When you refuse, the officer must read you a form from the Office of the Executive Secretary of the Supreme Court of Virginia. It explains that you are deemed to have consented, that a refusal can lead to the loss of your license, the civil penalties, and that a second breath refusal within 10 years is a Class 1 misdemeanor.
The officer must then swear before the magistrate that you refused, that the form was read to you, that you refused again after hearing it, and how many prior refusals or DUI convictions you have within 10 years. That sworn form is the probable cause for the refusal warrant. Each of those steps is something the defense can test.
Driving after a first refusal: the restricted license
Under § 18.2-268.3(F), a person found guilty of a first refusal, breath or blood, may petition the court for a restricted license for the rest of the suspension. If the court grants it, for good cause, it must order:
- an ignition interlock on each vehicle you own or that is registered to you, for at least 6 consecutive months without an alcohol-related violation and no longer than the suspension, and
- completion of the Alcohol Safety Action Program (ASAP), with a fee of $250 to $300.
A restricted license never covers a commercial motor vehicle. Anyone charged with refusal may also enroll in ASAP before trial and install an interlock, and that time counts toward the court's order later. See restricted license after a DUI.
How a refusal fits with the DUI case
- Same court. Under Va. Code § 18.2-268.4, the refusal is tried in the court that hears the DUI.
- Stacked license periods. Under Va. Code § 18.2-271, a license loss for DUI runs consecutively with any refusal suspension. A first DUI conviction plus a first refusal can mean two separate one-year periods.
- Refusal isn't proof of guilt. Under Va. Code § 18.2-268.10, your refusal is not evidence at the DUI trial, and the prosecutor cannot comment on it except in rebuttal. A refusal finding can be admitted only to explain why there is no test result, and not as evidence of guilt.
- No test doesn't mean no case. The Commonwealth can still try to prove you were under the influence from your driving, your behavior and the video.
- A plea can end the refusal. If you plead guilty to the DUI, § 18.2-268.4 allows the court to dismiss the refusal warrant.
- Appeal. A civil refusal is appealed like a misdemeanor. On appeal to the Circuit Court, either side can ask for a jury, and the Commonwealth must prove the refusal beyond a reasonable doubt.
How Jad defends a refusal
- The arrest. Implied consent applies only after a lawful DUI arrest made within three hours of the alleged offense. If either is missing, so is the duty to test.
- The form. Jad checks whether the officer actually read the advisement, whether you refused after hearing it, and whether the sworn certification matches the video.
- Unreasonable or not. The law punishes only an unreasonable refusal, and whether a refusal was unreasonable depends on the facts. And under § 18.2-268.2, a person who is physically unable to give a breath sample is to be given a blood test instead.
- The prior count. A second breath refusal is a crime only if the earlier refusal or DUI is within 10 years. Jad checks the dates and the records.
- The whole case. The refusal and the DUI are usually resolved together. Jad weighs both charges, and the license consequences of each, before recommending a path.